Goldberg Coins and Collectibles

Sale 117

September 13-16, 2020 Pre-Long Beach Auction

The Chuck Hall Collection

Lot	Photo	Description	Realized
Lot 111		1820 N-4 R4 Small Date PCGS graded AU55, CAC Approved. Lustrous tan and light steel brown with hints of underlying reddish steel faded down from mint color in a few of the protected areas on the obverse. Would be choice except for a couple light diagonal scratches in the field before the neck and chin and a small nick on the line below the E in CENT. E-MDS with segments of the inner circle still visible off the dentil tips on the left side of the obverse and the center dot on the reverse weak but visible. There are a couple shallow low spots inside the wreath caused by debris (lubricant) on the die. This cent is plated in John Wright's reference on the cents of 1816-1839 to illustrate the die variety. Graded AU50 and tied for CC#2 in the Noyes census, his photo #27786. Our grade is AU50. The attribution and Twin Leaf Collection provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36688. Pop 1; only 1 example graded higher in 64 at PCGS for the variety. Estimated Value $1,750 - UP Ex Denis Loring-R. S. Brown, Jr., Superior 9/30/1986:531-Stuart A. Hodge, 2002 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/20/2002:420-Jack Wadlington (The Twin Leaf Collection), Stack's Bowers 7/16/2015:2069-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Brown and Hodge collection envelopes, the Wadlington collection notes, and all 3 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $6,600
Lot 112		1820 N-5 R3 Small Date PCGS graded MS62 Brown. Glossy steel brown and chocolate with frosty lighter golden brown toning faded down from mint color in the fields and protected areas. This cent has excellent eye appeal with lots of underlying mint luster remaining on both sides. There is a small spot of reddish chocolate toning at the throat, and a speck of verdigris is located in the center of this spot. Otherwise just a few trivial contact marks including a tiny diagonal nick midway between star 1 and the chin. Sharply struck EDS with smooth, hard fields on both sides and parts of an inner circle visible at the dentils around more than half of the obverse. Called MS60 net AU55 and tied for CC#3 in the Noyes census, his photo #31165. Bland says AU55 and tied for CC#3 among the confirmed examples in his census. Our grade is AU55. Comes with a long provenance that includes several prominent cent collectors. The attribution and Dan Holmes provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36691. Pop 2; only 2 examples graded higher in 64 at PCGS for the variety. Estimated Value $2,500 - UP Ex J. C. Morgenthau & Co. 1939-Judge Thomas Gaskill, New Netherlands Coin Co. 12/7/1957:1399-Emanuel Taylor, Abe Kosoff 10/11/1961:471-R. E. Naftzger, Jr., Lester Merkin 9/1967:79-C. Douglas Smith-Dr. Bob Shalowitz 1979-Bill Noyes, 1983 EAC Sale, lot 350-Carvin Goodridge 4/4/1992-Wesley A. Rasmussen, Heritage Auctions 1/13/2005:3441-Daniel W. Holmes, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 5/30/2010:131-Greg Hannigan-Adam Mervis, Heritage Auctions 1/10/2014:2062-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Smith, Goodridge, Rasmussen, and Holmes collection envelopes plus the last 4 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $5,040
Lot 113		1820 N-6 R4 Small Date PCGS graded AU50. Very attractive glossy medium chocolate brown and steel. The surfaces are quite smooth and slightly prooflike on both sides. No spots or stains, only minor contact marks. The notable ones are a hairline scratch at the upper left point of star 12 and a small planchet flake under the right upright of the N in ONE. E-MDS. A very nice example of this tough die variety. Graded EF45 net EF40 and tied for CC#8 in the Noyes census, his photo #28593. Our grade is EF40+. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36694. Pop 1; 6 graded higher at PCGS for the variety, 2 in 55, 3 in 62, 1 in 63. Estimated Value $1,250 - UP Ex J. Sype-Joe Tomasko 9/1985-John D. Wright 1/18/2006-Bob Grellman & Chris McCawley 8/6/2014-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Wright collection envelope). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,740
Lot 114		1820 N-7 R2 Small Date PCGS AU Detail Environmental Damage. Mostly glossy dark olive brown and steel. Looks perfectly smooth to the unaided eye but a glass reveals rather uniform extremely fine roughness. The only roughness visible without a strong glass is some very light pitting above star 4. No verdigris or notable contact marks. EDS. The dentils, legends, and partial inner circle on the obverse are all sharp and there are no die cracks or flowlines on either side. A nice 1820 cent in spite of the imperfect surfaces. Our grade is AU50 sharpness net EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36697. Estimated Value $450 - UP Ex Macy�s Department Store (New York City) 6/1968-John D. Wright 1/18/2006-Bob Grellman & Chris McCawley 4/3/2006-Daniel W. Holmes, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 5/30/2010:134-Chris McCawley5/5/2012-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Wright and Holmes collection envelopes and lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $528
Lot 115		1820 N-8 R3 Small Date PCGS graded AU50. Choice glossy medium olive brown and chocolate. Peeps of golden tan faded down from mint color remain visible on the reverse and this cent has outstanding eye appeal. Nearly flawless; a tiny tick right of the D in UNITED is the only notable mark. MDS. Struck very slightly off center to K-4. Our grade is EF40 Choice. And it comes with a nice provenance. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36700. Estimated Value $500 - UP Ex Bruno Crossfield 12/1956-Willard C. Blaisdell 9/1976-Del Bland-Stuart A. Hodge 7/1984-Ed Jasper, 2005 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/23/2005:338-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Jasper collection envelope and lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $930
Lot 116		1820 N-9 R3 Large Date PCGS graded AU55. Frosty medium brown and chocolate with some darker steel toning on the obverse devices. Flowline luster covers the fields and protected areas, especially on the reverse. Would rate a slightly higher grade but there is a very light rim bruise between stars 1 & 2, another over the F in OF, and a third at the second A in AMERICA. These minor bumps do not catch your eye. MDS with microscopic flowlines in the fields. The fine repunching at the left bottom of the 0 in the date is dull but still visible and there are faint die cracks from the truncation to the top of the 8 and another curving down from the tip of the chin. A sharp cent, at the lower end of the condition census for the variety. Our grade is EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 2; 3 finer: 2 in 64, 1 in 64+. PCGS #36661. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Superior 1/28/1990:607-Philip Moore 6/5/2015-Tom Reynolds 6/18/2015-The Westwood Collection, Goldbergs 9/1/2019:70-The Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Superior and Goldberg lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,440
Lot 117		1820 N-9 R3 Large Date PCGS graded VF35. Glossy medium brown and light chocolate. No spots or stains and the planchet is smooth. The only notable mark is a small dig at the upper edge of the bust, and this mark does catch your eye. Otherwise the cent is quite nice, just lightly worn. MDS. The repunching at the left bottom of the 0 in the date is dull but clearly visible. Our grade is VF20+. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36661. Estimated Value $225 - UP Ex McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 9/10/2006:987-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $180
Lot 118		1820 N-10 R2 Large Date PCGS graded AU58, CAC Approved. Lustrous light to medium steel brown. Nicely struck and very attractive. Looks mint state but there is a hint of rub on the highest points of the devices. Essentially free of marks; just a few trivial ticks on the throat. MDS with fine radial die flowlines in the fields and the small dash left of the first A in AMERICA is still clear, but the center dot on the reverse is gone. Called "Uncirculated" by Blaisdell, Bland, and Naftzger. Noyes graded MS60 and tied for CC#5, his photo #20082. Our grade is AU55. Comes with a very nice provenance. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36664. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Homer K. Downing 4/5/1948-Willard C. Blaisdell 9/1976-Del Bland 9/1976-R. E. Naftzger, Jr.-Del Bland 4/1983-R. E. Naftzger, Jr., 1989 EAC Sale, lot 236-Walter Dudgeon, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 7/30/1994:43-Dr. Wallace Lee, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 5/25/2003:656-Chris McCawley, 2007 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/28/2007:385-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Blaisdell, Naftzger, and Lee collection envelopes and 3 lot tickets missing only the 2003 Superior lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,500
Lot 119		1820 N-11 R2 Large Date PCGS graded AU55, CAC Approved. Glossy medium steel brown and chocolate with frosty lighter brown and tan in protected areas. Peeps of faded mint red can be found on the reverse and this cent has excellent eye appeal. Essentially flawless, just lightly worn on the highpoints. A speck of darker toning off the lower right point of star 5 can help identify this cent. M-LDS. The inner circle on the obverse is gone but the repunching at the base of the T in CENT is still clear. Our grade is EF45. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36667. Estimated Value $600 - UP Ex Thomas D. Reynolds-unknown, 1999 EAC Sale, lot 421-Ed Jasper, 2005 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/23/2005:342-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Jasper collection envelope and both lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $720
Lot 120		1820 N-12 R3 Large Date PCGS graded AU58. Glossy light to medium chocolate brown and steel with frosty lighter steel brown toning in the protected areas. No spots or stains, only microscopic hairlines on the obverse and a very light diagonal scratch right of star 2. The reverse is choice, nearly flawless. Nicely struck E-MDS. The lump over star 4 is strong and microscopic radial die flowlines are starting to show off the dentil tips. This is the plate coin for the variety in John Wright's reference on the cents of 1816-1839, and it comes with a nice provenance. Graded AU50 and tied for CC#12 in the Noyes census, his photo #38533. Our grade is AU50 net EF45. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36670. Estimated Value $600 - UP Ex Lester Merkin 10/19/1966:136-R. S. Brown, Jr., Superior 9/30/1986:539-March Wells, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 2/7/2000:1823-Thomas D. Reynolds 2/15/2018-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Brown and Wells collection envelopes and all 3 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $930
Lot 121		1820 N-13 R1 Large Date PCGS graded MS64 Brown, CAC Approved. Lustrous medium brown and light chocolate with bluish steel overtones on the reverse. A barely perceptible puff of reddish brown toning at the top of STAT is the only notable mark. Sharply struck MDS, the usual Randall Hoard die state for this variety. Our grade is MS60+. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36673. Estimated Value $700 - UP Ex McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 9/20/2010:971-Chris Taylor, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 1/25/2015:476-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Taylor collection envelope and the last lot ticket)). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $960
Lot 122		1820 N-14 R5- Large Date NGC graded MS62 Brown. Very attractive frosty chocolate brown and steel with a hint of reddish chocolate toning at the 18 in the date. Satiny mint luster covers the fields and protected areas and this cent has great eye appeal. Looks mint state but there is a touch of friction on the highest points of the devices. The only notable mark, and it is insignificant, is a minor rim bruise at the U in UNITED. MDS. Both sides are covered with fine radial die flowlines, as always for this variety, which is the product of a brief marriage of worn-out dies. Called EF40 and CC#3 in the Bland census. Noyes says EF45 net VF35 and tied for CC#4, his photo #25234. Our grade is EF40+, close to EF45. The attribution and Mervis provenance are noted on the NGC label. Pop 1; the finest example graded at NGC for the variety, only 1 example graded higher in 66 BN at PCGS. Estimated Value $7,500 - UP Ex George Patterson-R. S. Brown, Jr., Superior 9/30/1986:542-Wesley A. Rasmussen, Heritage Auctions 1/13/2005:3456-Daniel W. Holmes, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 5/30/2010:145-Greg Hannigan-Adam Mervis, Heritage Auctions 1/10/2014:2071-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Patterson and Brown collection envelopes and 3 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $25,200
Lot 123		1820 N-15 R2 Small Date PCGS Unc Detail Planchet Flaw. Lustrous medium steel brown and light chocolate. Faint hints of faded mint red show in protected areas on the reverse and this cent is choice except for a mint-made planchet fissure between stars 3 & 4. This planchet flaw certainly catches your eye. Otherwise the only notable mark is a small spot of darker toning (not carbon) on the center of the neck. LDS with fine die rust on both sides (microscopic lumps on the coin). Our grade is MS60. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36703. Estimated Value $500 - UP Ex 2005 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/23/2005:347-Chris McCawley 9/30/2005-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $720
Lot 124		1821 N-1 R1 PCGS AU Detail Altered Surface. Glossy dark olive brown and chocolate with lighter brown toning on highpoints of the portrait. The surfaces are smooth and essentially void of marks, but the toning is darker than you like to see on a piece that is this sharp. We do not see evidence that the surfaces were "Altered." E-MDS before any die cracks but there is minor crumbling in the dentils left of star 7. Our grade is EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36706. Estimated Value $750 - UP Ex 1977 ANA Sale, Kagin's 8/23/1977:412-Carvin Goodridge Collection-Goodridge Estate, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 6/2/2013:406-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Goodridge collection envelope and Goldberg lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $780
Lot 125		1821 N-2 R1 NGC graded AU53. Attractive medium brown and light chocolate. No spots or stains, only minor contact marks scattered over both sides. A cent with excellent eye appeal, just lightly worn. A dull diagonal nick right of the date and a thin diagonal nick over the left side of the C in CENT may help identify this cent. Nicely struck EDS. The dentils are crisp around both sides and the die line from the bust tip is strong. Our grade is VF35+, close to EF40. The attribution is noted on the NGC label. Pop 2; 11 graded higher at NGC for the variety. Estimated Value $1,250 - UP Acquired by Chuck Hall from an unrecorded source on 4/21/2017. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,920
Lot 126		1822 N-1 R3 PCGS graded AU58. Frosty medium steel brown with lustrous lighter golden steel brown in the protected areas on both sides. The only notable marks are a couple light nicks off the right point of star 1 and a small puff of darker toning left of star 6. E-MDS with microscopic die flowlines but no evidence of die rust. A nice example of a variety that is difficult to find in high grade. Our grade is EF45. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 2; 5 finer: 2 in 63, 3 in 64. PCGS #36712. Estimated Value $600 - UP Ex Douglas F. Bird 5/5/2006-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $990
Lot 127		1822 N-2 R3 PCGS AU Detail Damage. Sharpness near mint state but there is a collection of very fine horizontal pin scratches below the line under CENT. Otherwise there are just a few trivial marks including a faint hairline on the jaw and a scuff of slightly lighter toning off the lower left point of star 12. Glossy olive brown and chocolate. Satiny mint luster covers the fields and protected areas and this cent has excellent eye appeal. Sharply struck E-MDS. The arc line left of the O in OF is sharp and there is crumbling in the upper notch of the N in CENT. The always-present die crack from above star 7 to star 12 is clear. Our grade is net AU50. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36715. Estimated Value $500 - UP Ex Walter Dudgeon, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 7/30/1994:50-Dr. Wallace Lee, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 5/25/2003:666-Tom Reynolds 6/4/2005-Philip Moore 6/12/2015-The Westwood Collection, Goldbergs 9/1/2019:83-The Chuck Hall Collection (includes all three lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $480
Lot 128		1822 N-2 R3 PCGS graded VF25. Glossy medium brown and light chocolate blending to darker chocolate brown in the protected areas. Smooth and attractive, just lightly worn. No notable marks, just trivial ticks consistent with the grade. MDS with the usual die cracks on the obverse. Our grade is VF20+. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 12 finer. PCGS #36715. Estimated Value $150 - UP Ex J. Koehart 10/26/2004-Colonel Steven K. Ellsworth 7/9 2005-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Ellsworth envelope). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $96
Lot 129		1822 N-3 R2 PCGS graded AU58. Glossy chocolate brown with lustrous lighter steel brown toning covering the protected areas. The reverse is a shade or two lighter than the obverse and has some small splashes of darker steel brown toning on the right side. A trio of very tiny ticks just right of the date are the only notable signs of contact. Nicely struck E-MDS. The fields are smooth and slightly reflective. A curved planchet clip (as struck) affects the dentils under the 22 and half way to star 13 plus on the opposing dentils above. Graded AU55 and tied for CC#3 in the Noyes census, his photo #28123. Our grade is AU50. A sharp, attractive cent with a minor but obvious mint error. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 3; 3 finer: 1 in 63, 2 in 64. PCGS #36718. Estimated Value $800 - UP Ex Coin City Coins (Denver) 5/1964-John D. Wright Collection 1/18/2006-Bob Grellman & Chris McCawley, 2009 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/18/2009:269-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Wright collection envelope and lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,320
Lot 130		1822 N-4 R2 NGC graded MS61 Brown. Frosty steel brown and chocolate with lighter golden steel brown in protected areas, particularly on the obverse. The fields are satiny and this cent has nice eye appeal. The only marks are a puff of darker toning between the date and star 13 and several nicks in the field below stars 7 & 8. The reverse is flawless. MDS. The inner circle from star 1 to star 8 is clear and there is no die crack from the bust tip. The portrait is very sharply struck. Our grade is AU55+. The attribution and Mervis Collection provenance are noted on the NGC label. Pop 3; 6 finer at NGC for the variety, 4 in 62, 2 in 65. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Adam Mervis, Heritage Auctions 1/10/2014:2079-Chuck Hall Collection (lot ticket included). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,680
Lot 131		1822 N-5 R3 PCGS graded AU50. Glossy dark steel brown with frosty lighter steel brown toning in protected areas. The surfaces are smooth except for a bit of microscopic roughness at AM in AMERICA. No verdigris and only trivial contact marks. MDS showing fine die rust on the neck (tiny lumps on the coin). Our grade is VF35. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 6 finer. PCGS #36724. Estimated Value $300 - UP Ex Thomas D. Reynolds 6/1/2006-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $600
Lot 132		1822 N-6 R3 PCGS graded MS62 Brown. Very attractive lustrous bluish steel brown with hints of golden tan faded down from mint color in protected areas. A thin swipe of darker olive toning right of star 5 and another over the E in ONE are the best identifying marks. Sharply struck very early die state with hard, slightly reflective obverse fields. This cent has great eye appeal; just a touch of rub on the highest points from choice mint state. Sold as MS63 in the Starr and Halpern sales and called "tied for finest known" in those catalogs. That claim is a bit optimistic, but the outstanding eye appeal of this cent can't be denied. Perhaps that's why this cent brought over $1500 in the 1988 Halpern sale. Graded AU55 net AU50 and tied for CC#7 honors in the Noyes census, his photo #35045. Our grade is AU58. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 4; 4 finer: 2 in 64, 2 in 65. PCGS #36727. Estimated Value $2,500 - UP Ex Jascha Heifitz, J. C. Morgenthau 12/22/1937-Floyd T. Starr, Stack's 12/4/1984:1621-Herman Halpern, Stack's 3/16/1988:387-Chris McCawley-John McGinty, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 2/10/2008:1449 (where it brought $3565)-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Goldberg lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $4,080
Lot 133		1822 N-7 R3+ PCGS Genuine AU Details Scratch. Frosty chocolate brown and tan with a few subtle puffs of reddish brown and darker olive toning. Sharply struck and attractive but there are a half dozen light scratches in the field before the portrait and a couple more between the stars above the head. The scratches barely break the toning and there are no additional marks. Sharply struck EDS. The outside leaf under IC in AMERICA is shallow but clear. Our grade is EF45+ sharpness net EF40. One of the sharpest examples known of this tough die variety. The attribution and Twin Leaf Collection provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36730. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Bowers & Merena 11/18/1993:1020 (plated)-Mike Greenspan, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 1/6/1996:335-Jack Wadlington (The Twin Leaf Collection), Stack's Bowers 7/16/2015:2098-Chuck Hall Collection (includes all 3 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,260
Lot 134		1822 N-8 R4 PCGS graded AU53, CAC Approved. Glossy steel brown and chocolate with frosty tan and light brown covering the protected areas on both sides. The surfaces are smooth and this cent is essentially flawless, just lightly worn on the devices. A collection of very tiny ticks in the field under the chin may help identify this cent, but you need a good glass to see them. Nicely struck E-MDS with a few very fine die cracks on the reverse. Graded VF30 Choice and tied for CC#4 in the Noyes census, his photo #27747. Our grade is VF30+. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 2 finer in 55. PCGS #36733. Estimated Value $1,500 - UP Ex Mid American-J. R. Frankenfield, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 2/17/2001:778-Thomas D. Reynolds-Bowers & Merena 6/28/2007:300-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Bowers lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $2,640
Lot 135		1822 N-9 R5- PCGS graded AU50. Medium olive brown and steel. Looks flawless to the unaided eye but a glass reveals uniform extremely faint roughness that subdues the gloss on both sides. Otherwise this cent is choice and the eye appeal is excellent. Sharply struck EDS. The die crack through ED STATES is quite faint (occurred during the previous N-8 marriage). Graded EF40 net VF30 and tied for CC#3 in the Noyes census, his photo #35704. Our grade is EF40. An important example of this tough die variety, and it comes with a nice provenance. The attribution and Twin Leaf Collection provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36736. Pop 1; 2 finer at PCGS for the variety, 1 in 53, 1 in 55. Estimated Value $5,000 - UP Ex Colonel E. H. R. Green 6/8/1936-Green Estate 4/1943-Burdette G. Johnson (St. Louis Stamp & Coin)-unknown-Spink America 6/31/1997:105 (group of 11 cents)-Thomas D. Reynolds 7/12/1997-Jack Wadlington (The Twin Leaf Collection), Stack's Bowers 3/30/2016:10059-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Green envelope, the Wadlington collection notes, and both lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $6,300
Lot 136		1822 N-10 R2 NGC graded MS65 Brown. Lustrous light chocolate brown with overtones of light bluish steel. A small spot of lighter brown toning close under star 4 and a few microscopic ticks on the cheek and in the field right of star 3 are the only marks. Nicely struck MDS with radial lines in most of the stars and the remaining details fully impressed. Portions of the inner circle remain visible at the tips of the obverse dentils and the rim is starting to dish at the top of the reverse. Called MS63 choice and tied for CC#2 in the Noyes census, his photo #35415. Bland says MS60+ and tied for CC#2. Our grade is MS63. A great cent that comes with a very nice provenance. The attribution and Mervis Collection provenance are noted on the NGC label. Pop 1; the finest example graded at both services for the variety. Estimated Value $2,500 - UP Ex Henry C. Hines-Floyd T. Starr, 1949 ANA Sale, lot 935-R. E. Naftzger, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldberg�s 2/1/2009:133-Daniel W. Holmes, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 5/30/2010:168 (in a PCGS MS64BN holder)-Greg Hannigan-Adam Mervis, Heritage Auctions 1/10/2014:2085-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Naftzger collection envelope and the last 2 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $8,100
Lot 137		1822 N-11 R2 PCGS graded AU58. Frosty light to medium brown with darker steel brown toning on the highpoints and lustrous tan faded down from mint color in protected areas. The only notable marks are a few small nicks in the field before the portrait, a small planchet flake in the field above the head (as struck), and a spot of dark reddish olive toning at UN in UNITED. MDS with fine radial die flowlines off the dentil tips. Our grade is EF40+. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 9 finer. PCGS #36742. Estimated Value $500 - UP Ex Dr. Robert J. Shalowitz 11/1984-John D. Wright Collection 1/18/2006-Bob Grellman &Chris McCawley, 2009 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 4/18/2009:278-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Wright collection envelope and lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $990
Lot 138		1822 N-12 R4 PCGS graded MS63 Brown. Frosty medium brown and light olive with a hint of light bluish steel overtone. Satiny mint luster covers the fields and protected areas and the eye appeal is excellent. The only notable marks are a diagonal nick in the field under the chin and a couple splashes of slightly darker brown toning under ENT in CENT. Nicely struck showing crisp hair details and full radial lines in all but the first 2 stars. E-MDS. The fields on the obverse are smooth and slightly reflective, and the fine die crack from the dentils through star 7 extends down the portrait to the bust tip where it fades away. A wonderful example of this tough die variety. Graded MS60 net AU50 and tied for CC#5 in the Noyes census, his photo #25223. Bland says MS60 and tied for CC#2. Our grade is AU58. This is the Newcomb plate coin for the variety in his reference on the cents of 1816-1857 (Plates III & IV). Comes with a very nice provenance. The attribution and Newcomb-Ahumada provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36745. Pop 1; only 1 example graded higher in 64 at PCGS for the variety. Estimated Value $6,000 - UP Ex Dr. George P. French (acquired by Dr. French prior to the 1914 ANS Exhibition), B. Max Mehl 1929 FPL, lot 441-Howard R. Newcomb, J. C. Morgenthau & Co., 5/16/1945:555-Floyd T. Starr, Stack's 6/13/1984:159-Wes Rasmussen, Heritage 1/13/2005:3473-Manuel Ahumada Collection, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 6/4/2017:63-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the inscribed Howard Newcomb collection pillbox, the Rasmussen collection envelope, and the last three lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $26,400
Lot 139		1822 N-13 R5 PCGS graded G4. Glossy dark steel brown and olive with peeps of lighter steel brown in protected areas. The surfaces are smooth, just well worn. The date is bold and the legends are clear. Our grade is G5. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 14 finer. PCGS #36748. Estimated Value $150 - UP Ex Harry Smith 3/15/1990-unknown-Chris McCawley, 2014 EAC sale, lot 234-Chuck Hall Collection (lot ticket included). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $132
Lot 140		1823/2 N-1 R2 Overdate 3 over 2 PCGS graded VF30, CAC Approved. Glossy medium steel brown and chocolate. Smooth and attractive, just lightly worn. The only notable mark is a rim nick below the end of the wreath ribbon. LDS with crumbling in the dentils below the 18 and from star 2 to star 4. The date is bold and the overdate feature is obvious. Our grade is VF25. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 14 finer. PCGS #36760. Estimated Value $300 - UP Ex 1985 EAC Sale, lot 399-Jim Corrado, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 2/2007:510-March Wells, 2011 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 5/14/2011:423-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Corrado and Wells collection envelopes and all 3 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,980
Lot 141		1823 N-2 R2 PCGS graded VF30. Glossy medium steel brown and chocolate. No spots, stains, or roughness, only light wear and minor contact marks. The only notable marks are a small nick on the front edge of the neck and a dull contact mark over the right point of star 13. E-MDS with clear rim cud breaks from star 4 to star 5 and a smaller one above star 6. Our grade is VF20+. A nice mid-grade example of a variety that is difficult to find in grades above Fine. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36757. Estimated Value $1,750 - UP Ex Chris McCawley 4/23/2015-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $3,000
Lot 142		1823 Restrike NGC graded MS64 Brown, CAC Approved. Glossy light olive and medium brown with mellowed red showing in protected areas. The only mark is a spot of carbon in the dentils below star 3. LDS with die cracks on both sides. Portions of the fields on both sides are reflective thanks to aggressive die polishing to remove rust from the die faces. These "Restrikes" were made outside the mint using discarded mint dies that had been sold as scrap. The obverse die used was the normal Newcomb-2 variety of 1823, but apparently a reverse die of the type used in 1823 was not available and they substituted a reverse die used for the 1813 Sheldon-293 variety. The result was an "1823" cent that looked nothing like the genuine mint product. Walter Breen says 49 uncracked examples were struck in 1862 for Joseph J. Mickley before the obverse die broke. Examples in the latest die state such as this piece with die cracks on both sides were struck beginning in 1879 according to Breen. Our grade is MS63. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Coin Rarities On Line FPL Winter 2012-13-Chris McCawley 12/18/2012-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,380
Lot 143		1824/2 N-1 R1 Overdate 4 over 2 PCGS graded AU53, CAC Approved. Choice glossy chocolate brown with hints of underlying lighter brown tones on the reverse. Satiny luster covers the protected areas and the eye appeal of this cent is outstanding. A tiny diagonal nick under star 8 and another dull tick under the left side of the O in ONE are the best identifying marks, and they are insignificant. MDS with minor crumbling in the dentils on the left side of the obverse. The overdate feature is clear. A common overdate variety but seldom seen this nice. Our grade is EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 3; 9 finer. PCGS #36778. Estimated Value $2,000 - UP Ex John Ward, Jr., 2/9/2002-Earl N. Sullivan, Jr., 2008 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 5/10/2008:450-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Sullivan collection envelope and EAC Sale lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $2,880
Lot 144		1824 N-2 R2 PCGS graded AU55. Frosty medium steel brown and chocolate with lighter brown and tan toning covering the protected areas. Mint luster shows in the fields and protected areas and this cent has excellent eye appeal. The only marks are a few tiny ticks at the bottom of the reverse under the wreath ribbon. MDS with minor crumbling in the two notches of the N in ONE. Graded EF40 in the Noyes census, his photo #61333. Our grade is EF45. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 6; 12 finer. PCGS #36769. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Thomas D. Reynolds 12/10/2011-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,440
Lot 145		1824 N-3 R2 PCGS graded MS63 Brown, CAC Approved. Frosty medium steel brown and light chocolate. The surfaces are lustrous and this cent looks mint state, but there are a few too many tiny contact marks for a mint state grade. The notable marks are some microscopic ticks in the field around stars 4-6 and a tiny rim bruise at the N in UNITED. LDS. The inner circle at the dentil tips on the obverse is gone and many of the dentils are weak or missing, but the portrait details are quite sharp. Graded MS60 net AU55 and CC#5 in the Noyes census, his photo #20451. Our grade is AU58. The attribution and Naftzger-Ahumada provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36772. Pop 4; 4 graded higher at PCGS for the variety, 3 in 64 BN, 1 in 65 RB. Estimated Value $5,000 - UP Ex Gene Sanders-Hillcrest Enterprises 6/5/1971-Jack Collins 10/3/1974-C. Douglas Smith 4/1980-R. E. Naftzger, Jr., 1989 EAC Sale 4/1989:268 (as MS60)-Manuel Ahumada Collection, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 6/4/2017:66-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Collins and Naftzger collection envelopes and both lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $6,600
Lot 146		1824 N-4 R2 PCGS AU Detail Cleaned. Choice glossy medium brown and chocolate (the toning looks original to us with no evidence of having been "Cleaned"). Smooth and very attractive; just lightly worn on the highpoints and void of any notable marks. Nicely struck LDS with a tiny hook from the die crack on the lowest point of star 12 and clear die clashmarks on both sides. Our grade is EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36775. Estimated Value $375 - UP Ex Ray Rouse, 2011 EAC Sale, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 5/14/2011:432-Chuck Hall Collection (lot ticket included). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $690
Lot 147		1824/2 N-5 R4 Overdate 4 over 2 PCGS graded VF35. Very attractive glossy chocolate brown and steel. The surfaces are smooth and the only mark is a tiny rim bruise below the 8 in the date. LDS with minor crumbling in the dentils on the left side of the obverse. A very nice example of this tough die variety. Graded VF25 net VF20 and tied for CC#7 in the Noyes census, his photo #60798. Our grade is VF20. The overdate feature is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36781. Pop 2; only 2 examples graded higher at PCGS for the variety, 1 in 58, 1 in 64. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Marcus Collection-Heritage Auctions 3/25/2010:132-Chuck Hall Collection (lot ticket included). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,680
Lot 148		1825 N-1 R4 NGC graded XF45. Glossy chocolate brown and steel with frosty lighter steel brown and tan in protected areas, particularly on the obverse. The planchet is smooth and the eye appeal of this cent is excellent. The only notable mark is a fine, old scratch at UNITED, and it blends perfectly into the natural toning. MDS with a clear die crack through the base of the date to dentils on both ends but no rim cud break. Graded VF30 net VF25 and tied for CC#12 in the Noyes census, his photo #56800. Our grade is VF30. The attribution and Rasmussen Collection provenance are noted on the NGC label. Estimated Value $1,250 - UP Ex Richard V. Punchard 12/1990-Wesley A. Rasmussen, Heritage Auctions 1/13/2005:3490-unknown-McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 9/24/2007:2218-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $2,160
Lot 149		1825 N-2 R2 PCGS AU Detail Cleaned. Frosty medium steel brown with darker chocolate toning on the devices. Probably recolored but the eye appeal is excellent. The only notable marks are a dull nick or planchet flake in the center of the cheek and a spot of reddish brown toning off the right side of star 9. MDS with two fine die cracks on the obverse and one on the reverse. Struck slightly off center to K-5 leaving some dentils off the planchet. Our grade is AU50 sharpness net EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36787. Estimated Value $400 - UP Ex Chris McCawley 1/5/2006-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $456
Lot 150		1825 N-3 R3 PCGS graded AU55. Very attractive frosty medium steel brown and light chocolate. The fields are satiny and the only marks are a few tiny planchet chips around the bust tip and a small puff of darker olive brown toning right of the date. MDS. The small lump in the field below star 5 is still visible and a faint die crack meanders down from the curl over star 13 to the top of the 5 in the date. Graded EF45 net EF40 and tied for CC#16 in the Noyes census, his photo #35937. Our grade is EF40+, close to EF45. The attribution and Twin Leaf Collection provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36790. Pop 2; 5 graded higher at PCGS for the variety. Estimated Value $1,000 - UP Ex Thomas D. Reynolds 10/10/1991-Gary M. Ruttenberg, McCawley & Grellman Auctions 8/17/1996:336-Jack Wadlington (The Twin Leaf Collection), Stack's Bowers 11/3/2016:1038-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Reynolds envelope, the Wadlington collection notes, and both lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,440
Lot 151		1825 N-4 R3 NGC graded AU50. Glossy medium brown and chocolate. Frosty flowline luster shows in some of the protected areas and this cent has excellent eye appeal. The surfaces are smooth and the only notable mark is a fine diagonal scratch under star 5. MDS. Both sides have fine die cracks but the final crack through the E in ONE to the N in CENT has not formed. Strong doubling from die bounce (machine doubling) shows on most of ONE CENT. Our grade is VF30+. The attribution is noted on the NGC label. Estimated Value $600 - UP Ex George Ramont 10/1975-Jules Reiver, Heritage Auctions 1/24/2006:19841-Colonel Steven K. Ellsworth-Chris McCawley 12/18/2012-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $552
Lot 152		1825 N-6 R3 PCGS graded AU58, CAC Approved. Choice frosty light steel brown and tan. Satiny mint luster covers the fields and protected areas and this cent has outstanding eye appeal. Looks mint state but there is a touch of friction on the highest points of the devices. No spots or stains. The only marks are a faint hairline under star 6 and a pair of light scratches over the O in ONE. LDS with faint die cracks on both sides. Graded AU50 and tied for CC#10 in the Noyes census, his photo #28194. Our grade is AU50. A very nice 1825 cent. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 4; 7 finer: 2 in 62, 1 in 63, 4 in 64. PCGS #36796. Estimated Value $900 - UP Ex Foreman 1988-March Wells, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 2/7/2000:1863-Dr. Wallace Lee, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 5/25/2003:697 ($1380)-Chris McCawley-Thomas D. Reynolds 12/13/2008-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,500
Lot 153		1825 N-7 R3 Repunched 5 PCGS graded AU53. Attractive glossy chocolate brown. The surfaces are smooth and nearly free of marks, and the eye appeal of this cent is excellent. A very light diagonal hairline scratch between stars 4 & 5 is the only notable mark, and it is barely visible. MDS. A fine but clear die crack reaches from the curl at star 13 down to the dentils just right of the date and rim crumbling shows at star 11 up nearly to star 10. The repunching on the 5 is sharp. Called VF35 Choice and CC#17 in the Noyes census, his photo #26819. Our grade is EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36799. Estimated Value $700 - UP Ex Rawls 5/1978:1245-Jules Reiver, Heritage Auctions 1/24/2006:19847-Chris McCawley 8/24/2006-Daniel W. Holmes, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 5/30/2010:202-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Holmes collection envelope and the last 2 lot tickets). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $1,260
Lot 154		1825 N-8 R3 PCGS graded XF40. Glossy medium steel brown and chocolate. Satiny mint frost shows in the fields and protected areas and this cent has excellent eye appeal. The only notable marks are some microscopic planchet chips hidden in the hair and a very light rim bruise at the first A in AMERICA. E-MDS with uncracked dies that are starting to show fine radial die flowlines off the dentil tips. Our grade is VF30. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 1; 8 finer. PCGS #36802. Estimated Value $375 - UP Ex Douglas F. Bird 6/1/2006-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $456
Lot 155		1825 N-9 R2 PCGS AU Detail Cleaned. Choice glossy medium steel brown with frosty golden tan faded down from mint color in protected areas. Nearly flawless with excellent eye appeal, and we see no evidence this cent has been "Cleaned." A tiny tick on the bridge of the nose and a very faint hairline over star 1 are the best identifying marks, and they are barely visible. LDS with a fine die crack from the forehead to the dentils over star 3. The die rust found in the earlier state is now gone; it was polished off the die. Our grade is EF40. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36805. Estimated Value $500 - UP Ex John D. Wright 6/30/1986-Daniel W. Holmes, Jr., McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 5/30/2010:206-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Wright and Holmes collection envelopes and the Goldberg lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $720
Lot 156		1825 N-10 R3 PCGS graded AU53. Very attractive glossy light olive and steel brown with satiny mint frost in protected areas. The surfaces are smooth and this cent is nearly flawless. The only notable mark is a speck of reddish brown toning near the hair under star 7. MDS with a fine die crack from the bust top to the dentils left of the date and no crumbling in the dentils. A choice cent with light wear on the devices. Our grade is VF35. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS population 2; 5 finer: 3 in 62, 1 in 64, 1 in 65+. PCGS #36808. Estimated Value $600 - UP Ex Douglas F. Bird 5/5/2006-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $384
Lot 157		1826 N-1 R2 NGC graded AU58, CAC Approved. Choice frosty medium chocolate brown and steel with lighter steel brown toning in protected areas. The surfaces are smooth, the strike is sharp, and this cent has outstanding eye appeal. Lightly worn on the highpoints; otherwise essentially flawless. EDS. The stray star points right of the 6 in the date are sharp and fine die polishing lines show at AM in AMERICA. The cud break over star 6 has not formed. Our grade is EF45 Choice. The attribution is noted on the NGC label. Pop 2; 4 graded higher at NGC for the variety. Estimated Value $650 - UP Ex Chris McCawley 5/3/2013-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $870
Lot 158		1826 N-3 R3 NGC graded AU58. Frosty olive brown and chocolate with a subtle hint of bluish steel overtone. No spots or stains; just lightly worn on the highpoints with trivial marks. The only notable mark is a thin diagonal nick over the N in ONE. MDS with crumbling in the dentils over star 6. The reverse is slightly misaligned to K-9 leaving most of the dentils at UNITED ST off the planchet. Our grade is EF45. The attribution is noted on the NGC label. Pop 2; 3 graded higher at NGC for the variety, 2 in 61, 1 in 63. Estimated Value $500 - UP Ex Thomas D. Reynolds 2/23/2017-Chuck Hall Collection. View details and enlarged photos	Realized $660
Lot 159		1826 N-4 R2 PCGS graded AU55, CAC Approved. Frosty steel and olive brown with traces of golden tan faded down from mint color in protected areas. Mint luster shows in the fields and protected areas, especially on the reverse. There is a touch of friction on the highpoints and just a few trivial marks. The notable ones are a spot of slightly darker toning at the hair under the right point of star 6, a diagonal nick between stars 4 & 5, and a trio of diagonal nicks under the right point of star 1. None of these marks is significant and this cent has excellent eye appeal. LDS. The dentils on both sides are worn and many are missing, but the repunching on the E's on ONE CENT remains strong. Our grade is EF45+. The attribution and Koshkarian provenance are noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36820. Pop 1; 8 graded higher at PCGS for the variety, 7 in MSBN, 1 in MSRB. Estimated Value $600 - UP Ex Steve Wirth, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 5/29/2005:1581-Haig Koshkarian, McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Goldbergs 2/12/2017:88-Chuck Hall Collection (includes the Koshkarian collection envelope and last lot ticket). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $840
Lot 160		1826 N-5 R2 PCGS AU Detail Cleaned. Glossy medium steel brown and olive with satiny mint frost covering the protected areas on both sides. Essentially flawless, just lightly worn on the highest points of the devices. The toning is attractive and we can not find evidence that this cent has been "Cleaned" as claimed by PCGS. The only marks are a few microscopic pinpricks over the O in ONE. MDS with crumbling in the dentils from star 5 to just beyond star 6. In addition there is a double profile on the portrait and most of the stars (caused by die bounce or "machine doubling.") Our grade is EF40+, close to EF45. The attribution is noted on the PCGS label. PCGS #36823. Estimated Value $325 - UP Ex Chris McCawley 3/1983-unknown-McCawley & Grellman Auctions/Superior 5/29/2005:1582-Chuck Hall Collection (lot ticket included). View details and enlarged photos	Realized $324

Page 2 of 6

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6